Copyright © 2007 IEEE. Reprinted from Computer Magazine, Dec. 2007.
This material is posted here with permission of the IEEE. Such permission of the IEEE does not in any way imply IEEE endorsement of any of Intetics’ products or services. Internal or personal use of this material is permitted. However, permission to reprint/republish this material for advertising or promotional purposes or for creating new collective works for resale or redistribution must be obtained from the IEEE by writing to [email protected].
By choosing to view this document, you agree to all provisions of the copyright laws protecting it.
The Changing World of Outsourcing
Outsourcing — a practice once considered controversial — has become wide-spread, not only with technology companies but also with the IT departments of firms another industries. The volume of tech offshore out-sourcing — in which companies in economically advanced countries send work to businesses in develop-in nations — has increased since the approach became popular during the economic boom of the mid1990s. During that time, the nature of the practice stayed largely the same.
Now, though, this appears to be changing.
For example, companies that handle outsourcing are beginning to consolidate, creating larger providers offering a broader range of services. At the same time, niche providers are emerging.
In addition, countries such as China are beginning to compete with India, the longtime outsourcing-services leader.
Once, large companies did most tech outsourcing. Now, smaller and mid-size companies are beginning to outsource work. Also, companies primarily used to outsource large projects, such as basic application development or call center operations. Now, as outsourcing becomes more widespread, businesses are starting to contract out smaller projects—including complex scientific and R&D projects—to more and more providers.
Various technical and market place developments have driven and enabled these changes. And industry observers expect more changes in the long run.
Technology-related outsourcing began in the early 1980s and grew rapidly in the mid-1990s. The driving forces included the expanding tech economy, increased pressure on IT departments to do more with their resources, the increasing complexity of managing IT and keeping up with rapidly advancing technologies, and the difficulty in finding IT workers in all skill areas, noted David Parker, vice president of IBM Global Technology Services’ Strategic Outsourcing operations. Since then, companies have out-sourced more than just IT functions. For example, they have used the approach to make their production, customer service, and other processes efficient and inexpensive by farming them out to businesses that have the necessary expertise and can perform them less expensively, Parker noted. This work includes help desk, datacenter, and network management operations; database administration; and server management.
There are outsourcing provider sin both economically advanced and developing countries. The latter are able to offer lower costs because workers there receive lower wages.
Offshore outsourcing has become controversial, especially in the US, where critics say it is a way for domestic companies to save money by taking jobs from local workers and moving them overseas.
Technology has helped change the face of outsourcing. For example, improvements in telecommunications and Internet-based technologies such as videoconferencing, instant messaging, and Internet telephony make communication faster and more widely available for outsourcing providers and their clients, noted Alex Golod, vice president of business development for Intetics, a global software-development company.
Legal issues are also important. Some businesses in developed nations are outsourcing work to overseas branches of domestic companies to have more legal recourse if problems occur, said Ashish Gupta, CEO of Evalueserve Business Research, a market-analysis firm.
Because more companies are farming out a greater variety of projects, there has been a prolife ration of outsourcing suppliers in recent years to meet the demand.
Meanwhile, as outsourcing companies have grown, they have looked for ways to reinvest profits, expand, and acquire new capabilities, noted Gupta. For these reasons, outsourcing is experiencing a number of merge sand acquisitions.
For instance, the US-based EPAM Systems became the largest software-engineering services provider in Central and Eastern Europe by acquiring Vested Development, a Russian software-development-services firm.
India’s Wipro acquired Info-crossing, a US infrastructure-management services provider, for $600 million. Wipro has since opened several software-development and IT-services offices in the US.
Among other recent outsourcing deals, IBM purchased Daksh, Computer Sciences Corp. bought Covansys, and Electronic DataSystems acquired MphasiS.
According to Intetics’ Golod, consolidation is a way for small and mid-size vendors to survive and grow while gaining efficiencies in marketing and operations, and for larger companies to acquire competitors and firms with niche skills.
India has been the leader in out-sourcing services since the mid-1990s, mostly because it has a large, educated, English-speaking tech workforce; low salaries; and a technology sector that has pursued the work for many years.
Market-research firm Gartner Inc. warns that a shortage of tech workers and rising wages could erode as much as 45 percent of India’s market share by next year. In addition, Indian outsourcers can’t handle the high volume of available projects.
According to Intetics’ Golod, com-petition is coming largely from places such as China, the Philippines, Eastern Europe, Latin America, and even developed countries like Ireland and Israel, as discussed in the side-bar “Developing Countries Join the Outsourcing Marketplace.”
Market-research firm IDC predicts that China will overtake India by 2011. Emerging low-wage countries that may also pull business from India over the next few years include Egypt, Malaysia, Pakistan, and Thailand.
Small-scale and niche outsourcing
Traditionally, outsourcing has en tailed big companies and large, long-term projects such as major application development or the operations of entire departments. Bigger companies have been more willing to pay for outsourcing than smaller ones, have had more tasks they could offload, and could pro-vide larger contracts than smaller businesses.
Now, though, more companies are competing with large outsourcing providers. This includes outsourcing providers targeting smaller businesses and smaller, shorter-term jobs — including minor testing and business-analysis projects — either to capture a market niche or to expand their customer base. This work can entail either parts of larger jobs or small, individual projects.
To remain competitive, the larger providers are also looking at the smaller end of the outsourcing market, in part by standardizing their offerings to make them less expensive, noted Parker.
Outsourcing consultancy TPI says the number of commercial outsourcing contracts of more than $50million, especially in the US, has declined.
According to TPI, many Indian providers are seeking smaller jobs than in the past and thus are expected to increase revenue from North American companies by 37 percent during the next two years, even though the region is outsourcing less work.
Niche outsourcing providers are well placed for the smaller contracts — often for more-focused projects —that are becoming more popular, said Peter Allen, TPI partner and managing director of marketing development.
The growth of niche outsourcing is contributing to multisourcing, in which companies farm out different parts of a project to multiple specialty service providers, said BrianC. Daly, public relations director forUnisys’ outsourcing business.
“This makes it possible to choose best-of-breed outsourcing firms to handle different tasks and to optimize costs,” noted Intetics’ Golod.
Developing Countries Join the Outsourcing Marketplace
India has been the leading offshore technology-outsourcing supplier for a decade. The country has leveraged several advantages, including low salaries and a big, English-speaking workforce with college degrees in technology fields. However, there have been growing opportunities for other developing countries to enter the outsourcing-ser-vices market. For example, there is more outsourcing work than India can handle. In addition, wages in India are rising. And companies in other countries are actively pursuing and promoting their services.
This country attracts outsourcing projects largely in areas such as low-end, PC-based application development, quality-assurance testing, system integration, data processing, and product development. India is even outsourcing work to China. Market-research firm IDC’s Global Delivery Index—which ranks locations according to criteria such as avail-able skills, political risk, and labor costs—said Chinese cities have made significant investments in infrastructure, English-language instruction, and Internet-connection availability. The country has undergone a massive telecommunications expansion as a result of national economic policy. Also, China is producing 400,000 college graduates in technology fields annually, said Kenneth Wong, managing partner at Smith Wong Associates, a China-focused US consulting firm. “Language issues are no longer the major handicap to China-based outsourcing,” noted Wong. “Many IT personnel in China today are US-educated. The Chinese government knows it has a way to go in reaching English-proficiency parity with India, but the signs are encouraging. “Paul Schmidt, a partner with outsourcing consultancy TPI, added that demand for the country’s outsourcing services is driven largely by multinational corporations looking for access to China’s domestic market and a presence in the rest of the Asia-Pacific region.
Russia’s principal outsourcing competencies include Internet programming, Web design, and Web-server and Web-database application development. The country has an educated, experienced labor force, with the world’s third-largest pool of engineers and scientists per capita. English competency is good for mid- to higher-level managers and acceptable for developers who communicate directly with clients, noted Alex Golod, vice president of business development for Intetics, a global software-development company.
Countries such as Belarus, Bulgaria, the Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland, Romania, and Ukraine specialize largely in application development, particularly for complex scientific projects or commercial products. The region has a solid educational base, producing qualified scientists and engineers, explained Golod. Also, he said, the workers in these companies prefer complex, challenging projects to simple coding. In addition, larger clients are interested in sending work to Eastern Europe because they want to diversify their outsourcing across geographic regions. Eastern Europe gets a lot of projects from Western Europe and the UK, which are in nearby time zones, as well as the US, he said.
Countries in this region—particularly Argentina, Brazil, and Mexico—specialize in outsourcing projects such as application development. They have the advantage of time-zone proximity to the US. This makes Latin America ideal for time-sensitive project sand work where the outsourcer must communicate quickly and regularly with the outsourcing company.
This nation has a large English-speaking population and is carving out a niche for call-center operations. Evalueserve Business Research, a market-analysis firm, reports that favorable factors include a 94 percent literacy rate, a high-quality telecommunications infrastructure, familiarity with Western corporate culture, and government initiatives such as exemptions from license fees and export taxes that have stimulated outsourcing growth. Also, wages are low.
Ireland has a favorable IT services infrastructure and is strong in software development and testing. Israeli outsourcing providers specialize in commercial software development, particularly security and antivirus products. Although both nations have higher labor costs than developing countries, they continue to attract business because of their well-educated workforces and stable governments.
Outsourcing new and more complex tasks
As outsourcers have gained more skills, companies are beginning to farm out more-difficult technology tasks. Banks and other businesses, for instance, are moving well beyond outsourcing low-level application-maintenance work and are increasingly relying on offshore providers for help with full-system projects. These include providing online banking capabilities, customizing enterprise-resource-planning systems, or conducting statistical and actuarial projects for insurance firms. Outsourcing the modernization of legacy applications is another area with significant potential. This would help, for example, companies that no longer have the in-house expertise to work with older applications written in languages such as Cobol and that don’t want to spend the time and money necessary tore write them in other languages.
Cost not the only factor
Companies are farming out work not only to save money but also to gain long-term access to outsourcing firms’ talent, as well as their innovative, creative, and advanced approaches, said Unisys’ Daly.
Many companies find recruiting to be a tedious and expensive process, with choices often limited by local manpower resources, added Rob Enderle, president and principal analyst with the Enderle Group, a market-research firm. Global outsourcing firms have access to extensive pools of talent and well-established recruiting procedures.
Industry observers expect offshore outsourcing to continue growing.
For example, Forrester Research, a market-analysis firm, estimates that software outsourcing will account for 28 percent of IT budgets in the US and Europe by 2009, up from 20percent in 2006.
Forrester also predicts that the number of overseas software developers working on projects for firms in developed countries will rise from 360,000 this year to about 1 million by 2009.
Companies will increasingly out-source telecommunications and Internet-based development because the technologies in these areas are based on international standards and are thus easy for offshore vendors to work on.
Security is a big concern for many companies, with the growing use of mobile technology and the increasing complexity of threats. More companies will thus outsource short-term and ongoing security efforts, as keeping up with the work them-selves will require too much time and money.
However, there may be a limit on growth prospects, Golod said. For example, he noted, international political and economic problems could reduce the amount of out-sourced work.
According to Enderle, outsourcers may face problems coordinating their work with customers as they take on a greater variety and number of clients and projects.
And, said Renga Rajan, technical director for Fast Pvt. Ltd.(www.fastindia.com), an Indian out-sourcing supplier, providers will face challenges keeping their prices down because of rising salaries for skilled workers in developing countries.
Neal Leavitt is president of Leavitt Communications (www.leavcom.com), a Fallbrook, California-based international marketing communications company with affiliate offices in Brazil, France, Germany, Hong Kong, India, and the UK. He writes frequently on technology topics and can be reach edit [email protected]
Editor: Lee Garber, Computer,[email protected]